This is the one we reach for first when we're building a snack board. September Farm's Sharp Honey Brook Cheddar arrives sealed in distinctive red wax. It's hand-dipped at the Rotelle family's farmstead creamery in Honey Brook, PA, where four generations of cheesemaking expertise go into every block. Made from fresh whole milk sourced from local dairies, the curds are hand-packed, pressed, and aged until the cheddar develops that firm, slightly crumbly texture and clean, tangy sharpness that sets farmstead cheese apart from anything you'll find at a grocery store.
At Lancaster Gift Box, we love it sliced alongside Hammond's sourdough pretzels, sweet bologna, a good pickle, and a smear of mustard–the kind of snack board that becomes the centerpiece of the evening. Featured on Food Network's Will Work for Food, and earning national recognition for good reason.
Honey Brook, PA
September Farm is a fourth-generation family creamery tucked in Honey Brook, PA, where David and Roberta Rotelle make small-batch farmstead cheeses from fresh whole milk sourced from local dairies. Every block is hand-packed, aged, and dipped in wax using time-honored method, and the results speak for themselves. National award-winners, American Cheese Society honorees, and featured on Food Network's Will Work for Food.
8oz bar. Sealed in red wax. Contains milk. Refrigerate after opening.
Ingredients: pasteurized milk, salt, rennet, cheese culture

Every Purchase Gives Back
At Lancaster Gift Box, we believe in protecting the land and caring for the people it feeds.
That’s why we donate 1% of our sales to support local farms and hunger relief organizations, working with the Hunger‑Free Lancaster County community coalition
-
Our Guarantee
All sales are final due to the nature of our food products. However, we're dedicated to ensuring a great experience. If any items arrive damaged, like a broken pickle jar, we'll gladly replace them. Just reach out to us at help@lancastergiftbox.com.
-
Shipping Policy
As a family-owned business, we take pride in carefully preparing and shipping each order with attention to detail. Please allow 48 hours for processing. We use USPS Priority shipping, which typically takes 1-3 days to arrive. We ship Monday–Thursday.
-
Delivery Addresses
Please double-check the shipping address before finalizing at checkout. We ship orders to the address provided at checkout and are not liable for returned packages or packages sent to incorrect addresses. Read our FAQs here.