This is the one featured in our Taste of Lancaster Collection, and it earns its place every single time. English-style toffee made from a generations-old family recipe, coated in rich dark chocolate and finished with a generous dusting of sea salt that cuts through the bitterness beautifully and keeps you reaching back into the bag. Buttery, crunchy, sweet, and salty in exactly the right balance. A Team Gift Box favorite and a Lancaster cult classic that has been making appearances in our gift boxes since the very beginning.
Pair it alongside a bag of Amos & Annie's Gluten-Free Caramel Popcorn or with a strong cup of espresso for a pairing that leans fully into the dark and bold.
8oz bag.
Lancaster, PA
Lancaster Toffee Co. started the way the best food businesses do: with a grandmother's recipe, a holiday tradition, and friends who would not stop asking for more. Bonnie, the founder, spent years making her grandmother's English-style toffee every Christmas and giving it away to the people she loved. Eventually the demand became impossible to ignore, and Lancaster Toffee Co. was born. A decade later, it is one of our cult-favorite snacks at Lancaster Gift Box, a staple in many of our gift boxes, and the thing Team Gift Box reaches for first whenever a sweet treat is needed. Now E&A Candies is carrying on Bonnie's legacy as she steps back to spend time with her first grandchild.
Ingredients: chocolate (sugar, chocolate liquor processed with alkali, cocoa butter, milk fat, soy lecithin (an emulsifier, and vanilla); butter (pasteurized cream, salt), sugar, water, sea salt.
Contains: milk, soy. Made in a facility that processes tree nuts.

Every Purchase Gives Back
At Lancaster Gift Box, we believe in protecting the land and caring for the people it feeds.
That’s why we donate 1% of our sales to support local farms and hunger relief organizations, working with the Hunger‑Free Lancaster County community coalition
-
Our Guarantee
All sales are final due to the nature of our food products. However, we're dedicated to ensuring a great experience. If any items arrive damaged, like a broken pickle jar, we'll gladly replace them. Just reach out to us at help@lancastergiftbox.com.
-
Shipping Policy
As a family-owned business, we take pride in carefully preparing and shipping each order with attention to detail. Please allow 48 hours for processing. We use USPS Priority shipping, which typically takes 1-3 days to arrive. We ship Monday–Thursday.
-
Delivery Addresses
Please double-check the shipping address before finalizing at checkout. We ship orders to the address provided at checkout and are not liable for returned packages or packages sent to incorrect addresses. Read our FAQs here.